New York Medical College to stop using live dogs
By LEAH RAE
THE JOURNAL NEWS
(Original publication: November 27, 2007)
VALHALLA - The newest class of students at New York Medical College will study the basics of cardiology without the traditional method: They won't be opening the chest of a live dog and watching its heart beat.
Responding to appeals from humanitarian groups, the college said yesterday that it would end the practice normally used to teach 190 students in first-year physiology class. Echocardiography and simulators will replace the use of live dogs when they reach that phase of their course in early 2008.
The college attracted a mini-movement of opposition over the past two years as the only medical school in New York that apparently still used animals. Animal-rights groups, neighborhood dog lovers and politicians joined the cause.
Bob Funck, who lives in Harrison, said he began fighting the policy after hearing about it from a student. "I give the folks at the college credit for making
a good, positive decision - for them and for the animals," he said.
An organization called the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine is fighting the practice around the country. Just 11 medical schools still use live animals, none of them in New York state, said Dr. John J. Pippin, a Dallas cardiologist working with the organization. He said technological tools have quickly become the standard in education.
Dr. Karl Adler, president of the college in Valhalla, said that last he had heard,
about seven dogs were used annually in the lab. The animals were given anesthesia during the procedure and euthanized afterward, administrators have said.
"The reason why the dogs were used in the past is that the students could
actually see a beating heart, and understand the physiology of how the heart works,"
Adler said. "It's the only internal organ where there's actually movement
that you can understand the physiology of."
Animals were once a common study aid, he said. An internist, Adler remembers learning about treatment for seizures in a medical school lab with a number of seizing dogs.
Technology has since provided alternative ways to display and simulate the heart's function. With a portable echocardiograph machine, the class will be able to attach an electrode to a student's chest and watch the heart's activity on a video monitor. Simulators with computerized models will be able to mimic things like cardiac arrest or the effect of a drug.
New York Medical College's curriculum committee was asked in July to study
alternatives to the animal lab, and reported back to the dean that the alternatives were just as effective in instruction. Adler had no estimate on how much the college would spend on the technology.
"We're not teaching open-heart surgery. What we're teaching is first-year
medical students to understand how the heart works," he said. "And we
think that the exposure using (echocardiography) and the simulators is equivalent now to using a live dog."
Among the elected officials pressing against the practice was Assemblyman Adam Bradley, who wrote to the college dean, Dr. Ralph O'Connell, this month.
Bradley called the procedure "unjustified and unnecessary.
that the practice could not have been a great benefit to graduates, given that students were already allowed to opt out.
Typically, animals in a lab are anesthetized and given a breathing tube, and students open the chest, observe the heart and give drugs intravenously to watch the effects, said Pippin, the Dallas cardiologist. Modern simulators, in the form of humans, replicate the process so well that students can become emotional when the device simulates death.
The advantage: "You get to go back and learn and do it all over again and
be successful, as opposed to using a dog, where if you do make a mistake and the dog dies, you're done," he said. "The traditional notion that, 'Well,
we're going to use an animal to show you this 'cause we don't know how
else to do it' - that doesn't hold water anymore, because there are much
better ways to do it."
Reach Leah Rae at firstname.lastname@example.org or 914-694-3526.